Jan 01, 2018 hamid dalwai leads the first muslim womens march in 1966. What i want to expose today is muslim communalism which has already divided the motherland, and which is still strong enough to poison our body. Aka pula deshpande described him as a great social reformer and put him in the same bracket as the great indian leaders mahatma. On the hard dark stone the title of his book leapt out for attention. Muslim politics in secular india by hamid dalwai goodreads. These makers of modern india did not speak in one voice.
Shadi hamids islamic exceptionalism and the meaningless. Secularism is the concept that government or other entities should exist separately from religion and or religious beliefs. The topics they explore and analyse include religion, caste, gender, language, nationalism, colonialism, democracy, secularism and the economy that is to say, all that is significant in the human condition. Muslim politics in secular india orient paperback dalwai, hamid umar on. The recent massacres of innocent hindus in godhra, presumably ignited by smouldering muslim resentments against the hindutva proponents over ayodhya. In this animated interview by the atlantic, hamid explains how not only was the prophet mohammed a religious figure, he was a politician.
The supreme court judgement forces us to relook at what indian secularism really. On the other hand, all kinds of anxieties and doubts beset secularism in india. I bought it for something like twenty rupees, and took it home to bangalore. Explore hamid dalwai profile at times of india for photos, videos and latest news of. Bulgaria, secularism, state socialism, womens emancipation, yugoslavia p in his in. In this sense, he was the first revolutionary social thinker in the muslim world. Social context india is an ancient land of religious pluralism and cultural diversity.
Yes secularism is an import just like cricket and english language. In other words, it is not the goal of this article to argue that because secularism is a particular good, it is a. The supreme court judgement forces us to relook at what indian secularism really is. Hamid dalwai leads the first muslim womens march in 1966.
The topics they explore and analyse include religion, caste, gender, language, nationalism, colonialism, democracy, secularism and the economy. Hamid dalwai criticised the rss for its stand and it tried to thwart one of his meetings in nagpur as dalwai was insisting that the majority in the country must be secular and not religious. Of course, isis does that, too, but it attempts to build something in the place of what it has destroyed. The hindus who have had a vigorous tradition of pluralism and social reform have ceded ground to the hardliners. The case for reform of islam in india indiafactsindiafacts.
But i write down these opening features of secularism at the outset because they seem to me to be invariant among the different forms that secularism may take in different contexts. Hamid umar dalwai 20 september 1932 3 may 1977 was a social reformer, thinker, activist. A documentary about hamid dalwai, the man who led the triple talaq stir while bjp celebrates the passage of the muslim women protection of rights on marriage bill, in the lok sabha and claims credit for it, not many may be aware of the struggle of muslim reformist hamid dalwai, who first raised the demand to scrap. Culture culture presents reflections on such nonserious but nontrivial matters as music. Islam and secularism, syed muhammad naquib al attas. Romila thapar cites hseun tsang and kalhana as referring to hostilities between the shaivites and the buddhists. Critics claim the indian form of secularism as pseudo secularism. Dalwai, who was a member of the seva dal, was also a noted writer in marathi, and a rare. Isis has gone well beyond the alqaeda model of terrorism and destruction. Even during the protestant reformation, the governing principle was cujus region, ejus religio whatever the religion of the ruler that would be. Medical doctor narendra dabholkar, the founder of the main rationalist society in maharashtra and staunch secular campaigner whose murder in 20 was internationally reported, gave his son the islamic name hamidprobably in honour of hamid dalwai, who in 1977 founded the indian secular society quack 2012b. Shah in the indian secular society was the well known social activist mr.
Jan 19, 2015 the case for reform of islam in india speaking about the risk of a likely lone wolf attack in india, maharashtra state police chief sanjeev dayal told a newspaper in january. The muslim majilis mushawarat, which is the united front of muslim organizations in india, includes. Aug 20, 2016 though secularism has been pronounced as part of the basic structure of the indian constitution by the supreme court, an ambiguity about its meaning and practical implication continues to exist. The analysis and interpretation of islam and the politics of muslim community by hamid dalwai was revolutionary. I want to now turn from features that define or characterize secularism to features of its justification and basis of adoption. Scintillating and thoughtprovoking, this book gives an absorbing summing up of the problem of muslim communalism in india. It was presided over by the late shri jayaprakash narayan jp. He added that the congress has failed to take a clearcut secular position before the indian society which is in grave need of secularization. Secularism in india, secularism in india essay, indian. Secularism in india i do not expect india of my dreams to develop one religion, i.
In practice, unlike western notions of secularism, indias secularism does not separate religion and state. To understand secularism in india, we need to understand secularism in general, its origins in europe, protestantism versus roman catholicism, christianity versus judaism, the role of church, european history and the conditions under which secularism was imported to india. However, the constitution that came in to force with effect from 26 the january, 1950 did not use the word secularism. Amartya sen on his propositions on indian democratic spirit being rooted in distant history of the buddhist councils of the mauryans or indian secularism on the syncretism of. Secular or non religious is the idea of something 2. Supporters of the indian concept of secularism claim it respects minorities and pluralism. Even open source internet archive does not have a copy. The case for reform of islam in india speaking about the risk of a likely lone wolf attack in india, maharashtra state police chief sanjeev dayal told a newspaper in january. It is a pity that hamid dalwai is hardly taught in our schools just as tarabhai shinde on her ideas of equality of indian women and men. From ram mohan roy to hamid dalwai, its a nice book to start the adventure of exploring these ideas and the problems that they seek to solve. Commitment to confusion and the pedagogy of the name.
Mehrunnisa dalwai, wife of prominent muslim activist and thinker late hamid dalwai 19321977 and the protagonist of a reformist movement muslim satyashodhak mandal, passed away at 87 at her residence in pune in the indian state of maharashtra on thursday, 8 june 2017. Secularism is first and foremost a doctrine that opposes all such for ms of inter religious domination. Hamid ansari on being indian, muslim and secular youtube. This largest democracy on the globe is a federation of 35 constituents 28 fullfledged states and seven union territories, two of which are selfgoverning and the rest ruled by the central. A veteran journalist and provocative publicist, hamid dalwai has long crusaded for a secular outlook among the new generation of indian muslims. Twenty years ago i had been invited to a seminar on hurdles to secularism. Through the medium of this society, hamid worked towards reforming bad practices in the muslim community especially towards women.
Vaidya says dalwai believed in the constitution and secularism. Muslims, on the other hand, have never had a far sighted group of reformers of the likes of nehru or gandhi, except perhaps hamid dalwai. You read earlier in this chapter about untouchability. An indian scenario 69 devoid of religious conflicts at the mass level. In fact, for much of the middle easts existence, there. Dalwai joined the indian socialist party of jai prakash narayan in his early adulthood, but left it to devote himself to social reforms in the muslim community, especially regarding womens rights. This is a good example where members of the second way in which indian secularism works to prevent the above domination is through a strategy of noninterference. While arifs courageous position on the shah bano judgment was indeed praiseworthy, is it not ironical that one of the. The working paper had been prepared by the late professor a.
Jan 04, 2017 the system has multiple layers and is a highly complex process. Hamid umar dalwai 20 september 1932 3 may 1977 was a muslim social reformer. Secularism as practiced in india, with its marked differences with western practice of secularism, is a controversial topic in india. Its aim is to place traditional religion on the back burner of life and to instill a completely new way and outlook on life. But having said that, i also slightly disagree with hamid dalwai. The system has multiple layers and is a highly complex process. Hamid umar dalwai 20 september 1932 3 may 1977 was a muslim social reformer, thinker, activist and marathi language writer in maharashtra, india quotes. Excerpts from his book muslim politics in secular india. Concept, scope and its importance 34 and embitter the religious conflicts in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries11.
The indian constitution has allowed extensive interference of the state in. The 1984 antisikh riots, also known as the 1984 sikh massacre, was a series of pogroms targeting sikhs by anti. The religious identity of more than 20 million indian sikhs is also under siege. Although little known today, hamid dalwai was perhaps the most courageous thinker to come. Hamid dalwai dealt with opposition with tremendous equanimity and worked towards social reform without getting discouraged at the slow rate of success. Hamid dalwai, the man of todays india there was a great commotion in india, and pandit nehru had to take up the matter in his next weekly meeting with liaqat ali in lahore. Jul 16, 2016 in this animated interview by the atlantic, hamid explains how not only was the prophet mohammed a religious figure, he was a politician. Traditional religion taught that man lives for gd and is here on earth to serve him. Officially, secularism has always inspired modern india. It is because of these traits that the great marathi genius p.
With the fortysecond amendment of the constitution of india enacted in 1976, the preamble to the constitution asserted that india is a secular nation. The author, hamid dalwai belongs to a middleclass marathi speaking, muslim family. Oct 14, 20 it is a pity that hamid dalwai is hardly taught in our schools just as tarabhai shinde on her ideas of equality of indian women and men. On the one hand, almost every politician swears by it. This is the book muslim politics in secular india by hamid dalwai, 1968, as ente. Hamid dalwai the burden of history the challenge of secularism. Despite living in a period when most people were staunchly religious and orthodox, hamid dalwai was one among the few religiously secular people. Even during the protestant reformation, the governing principle was cujus region, ejus. Nov 18, 2019 vaidya says dalwai believed in the constitution and secularism.
Hamid dalwai, the man who led triple talaq stir in 1967 livemint. Though secularism has been pronounced as part of the basic structure of the indian constitution by the supreme court, an ambiguity about its meaning and. This is however only one crucial aspect of the concept of secularism. In the light of this development, it is worth remembering the writings of her husband hamid dalwai, who died very young. The razing of the babri masjid in ayodhya led to riots and killings by muslims and by hindus. Articles by ramachandra guha retrieved from his archives. Politics and current affairs politics and current affairs reproduces writings on secularism, majoritarianism, diversity, and other contentious themes in contemporary india. If secularism has its relevance only in context, then it is natural and right to think that it will appear in different forms and guises in different contexts. Secularism in india is widely considered to be under threat. Despite considerable effort, he could get together a mere seven muslim women to participate in the march organised on april 18,but it was a first step. Hamid dalwai criticised the hwmid for its stand and it tried to thwart one of his meetings in nagpur as dalwai was insisting that the majority in the country must be secular and not religious.
48 535 1526 610 1402 195 73 1249 188 1210 145 680 440 1374 800 1507 577 1158 1073 1480 1205 517 88 517 476 1504 525 323 129 1019 1195 591 476 1221 160 830 700 704 1345 26 714 756 1313 1152 1143 213 279 1084